Skip to main content
Second Nature
Sign In

Keeneyville Arsenal

Independent hunting and gun store in Middlebury Center, Pennsylvania (Tioga County).

Own this shop? Sell your gear here — free →

Visit Keeneyville Arsenal

Address
983 Route 249, Middlebury Center, PA 16935 Directions →
Type
Independent dealer

ATF-licensed dealer per federal firearms records (May 2026) — you can verify any license via ATF FFL eZ Check. Hours and inventory change — call before you drive.

Is this your license? Correct or remove this listing.

About Keeneyville Arsenal

Keeneyville Arsenal is an independent, federally licensed hunting and gun store at 983 Route 249 in Middlebury Center, Pennsylvania, in Tioga County. It's one of 2 independent hunting and gun stores in Middlebury Center and the surrounding area.

Gearing up for the season? Compare in-store prices against used hunting gear from verified sellers — or turn last season’s kit into cash.

More Stores Near Middlebury Center

Shop Used Hunting Gear

Premium brands from verified sellers, shipped anywhere in Pennsylvania — up to 60% off retail.

Valo Proximity Set
Like New
Kuiu · Size 2XL

Valo Proximity Set

$220.00$299.00
First Lite Corrugate Foundry Pant
Fair
First Lite · Size 32

First Lite Corrugate Foundry Pant

$130.00$220.00
First Lite Corrugate Guide Short
Like New
First Lite · Size 32

First Lite Corrugate Guide Short

$50.00
First Lite Trace Quarter Zip
Like New
First Lite · Size M

First Lite Trace Quarter Zip

$70.00$100.00
First Lite Uncompahgre Puffy Pant
Fair
First Lite · Size M

First Lite Uncompahgre Puffy Pant

$88.00$195.00
First Lite Trace Quarter Zip
Good
First Lite · Size M

First Lite Trace Quarter Zip

$60.00$100.00
First Lite Straightline Field Vest
Like New
First Lite · Size M

First Lite Straightline Field Vest

$140.00$225.00
First Lite Primer Puffy Vest
Like New
First Lite · Size M

First Lite Primer Puffy Vest

$125.00$185.00
Browse All Gear