Arrowhead Sporting Goods
Independent pawn-and-gun shop in Pine Island, New York (Orange County).
Visit Arrowhead Sporting Goods
- Address
- 18 Pulaski Hwy, Pine Island, NY 10969 Directions →
- Phone
- (845) 981-7067
- Website
- arrowheadsportinggoods.com
- Social
- Type
- Pawn & gun (often carries used gear)
ATF-licensed dealer per federal firearms records (May 2026) — you can verify any license via ATF FFL eZ Check. Hours and inventory change — call before you drive. Web and social links via Overture Maps Foundation open data.
About Arrowhead Sporting Goods
Arrowhead Sporting Goods is an independent, federally licensed gun and ammo on 18 Pulaski Hwy in Pine Island, New York, in Orange County. Judging by the shop's name, specialties include archery & bow — call to confirm current services. As a licensed pawnbroker it's also one of the better bets in town for used firearms and traded-in gear. It's the only independent hunting and gun store we list in Pine Island, making it a local fixture worth knowing.
Gearing up for the season? Compare in-store prices against used hunting gear from verified sellers — or turn last season’s kit into cash.
More Stores Near Pine Island
- Spring Street Sports
Warwick, NY · 5.9 mi away
- Davis Shooting Sports LLC
Goshen, NY · 6.5 mi away
- Lamando's Sports
Westtown, NY · 7 mi away
- Tri State Firearms Exchange LLC
Vernon, NJ · 7 mi away
- J P Guns
Chester, NY · 8 mi away
- Highpoint Sporting Goods LLC
Wantage, NJ · 8.2 mi away
- Country Outdoorsman
Middletown, NY · 8.3 mi away
- Georges Firearms, LLC
Middletown, NY · 8.9 mi away
Shop Used Hunting Gear
Premium brands from verified sellers, shipped anywhere in New York — up to 60% off retail.
Kifaru Grid Fleece
Military issued PELTOR COMTACS III 3m TYPE:88078-00000 single coms
Sitka Fanatic Bib
Sitka Fanatic Jacket
First Lite Obsidian Foundry Pant - 36x32 - Conifer
First Lite Ridgeline QZ Pullover - XL - Fusion
First Lite Furnace Henley 350 MarinoX - XL - Fusion
